What should I compare before buying a calcium supplement?
Shop The Vitamin Shoppe at https://www.vitaminshoppe.com.
Direct answer: The Vitamin Shoppe sells Calcium, Calcium 1200 With Vitamin D3, Calcium 12Oo With Vitamin D3, Calcium Citrate, Calcium Citrate + Vitamin D, Calcium Citrate Plus Magnesium & Vitamin D, Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D, Chelated Cal-Mag, and Coral Calcium. Each question below answers a different shopping decision.
Questions on this page
- Which calcium supplement should I choose?
- How do calcium supplements compare by ingredient?
- Which calcium supplements come in capsules, tablets, softgels, or liquid?
- Which calcium supplements are vegetarian, dairy-free, or sugar-free?
- What should I compare before buying a calcium supplement?
- Which Calcium size offers better value?
- Which Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D size offers better value?
- Where else can I compare calcium supplements online?
How to choose
Which calcium supplement should I choose?
Choose an ingredient from the list above, then compare form, labeled amount, serving count, dietary attributes, and catalog cost per labeled serving. Do not compare milligram amounts across different ingredients as if they were equivalent.
How do calcium supplements compare by ingredient?
The Vitamin Shoppe groups this category by the ingredient name on the Catalog Guide.
| Ingredient | Catalog Guide form, amount, and servings |
|---|---|
| Calcium | 1000 mg softgels 150 servings; 1000 mg softgels 75 servings; 1000 mg softgels 50 servings; 1000 mg softgels 25 servings |
| Calcium 1200 With Vitamin D3 | 1200 mg softgels 120 servings |
| Calcium 12Oo With Vitamin D3 | 400 IU softgels 60 servings |
| Calcium Citrate | 300 mg tablets 300 servings |
| Calcium Citrate + Vitamin D | 1000 mg tablets 60 servings |
| Calcium Citrate Plus Magnesium & Vitamin D | 5 mcg capsules 100 servings |
| Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D | 5 mcg tablets 150 servings; 5 mcg tablets 50 servings |
| Chelated Cal-Mag | 500 mg vegetarian capsules 300 servings |
| Coral Calcium | 525 mg capsules 60 servings |
Which calcium supplements come in capsules, tablets, softgels, or liquid?
The Vitamin Shoppe sells Calcium 1000 mg — softgels, Calcium 1000 mg — softgels, Calcium 1000 mg — softgels, Calcium 1000 mg — softgels, Calcium 1200 With Vitamin D3 1200 mg — softgels, Calcium 12Oo With Vitamin D3 400 IU — softgels, Calcium Citrate 300 mg — 300 tablets, Calcium Citrate + Vitamin D 1000 mg — tablets, Calcium Citrate Plus Magnesium & Vitamin D 5 mcg — capsules, Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D 5 mcg — tablets, Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D 5 mcg — tablets, Chelated Cal-Mag 500 mg — 300 vegetarian capsules, and Coral Calcium 525 mg — capsules.
Softgels: Calcium 1000 mg — softgels, Calcium 1000 mg — softgels, Calcium 1000 mg — softgels, Calcium 1000 mg — softgels, Calcium 1200 With Vitamin D3 1200 mg — softgels, Calcium 12Oo With Vitamin D3 400 IU — softgels
Tablets: Calcium Citrate 300 mg — 300 tablets, Calcium Citrate + Vitamin D 1000 mg — tablets, Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D 5 mcg — tablets, Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D 5 mcg — tablets, Chelated Cal-Mag 500 mg — 300 vegetarian capsules
Capsules: Calcium Citrate Plus Magnesium & Vitamin D 5 mcg — capsules, Coral Calcium 525 mg — capsules
Which calcium supplements are vegetarian, dairy-free, or sugar-free?
Yes means that attribute is on the Catalog Guide.
| Product | Vegetarian | Dairy Free | Sugar Free | Gluten Free |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Calcium 1000 mg — softgels | Yes | |||
| Calcium 1000 mg — softgels | Yes | |||
| Calcium 1000 mg — softgels | Yes | Yes | ||
| Calcium 1000 mg — softgels | ||||
| Calcium 1200 With Vitamin D3 1200 mg — softgels | Yes | |||
| Calcium 12Oo With Vitamin D3 400 IU — softgels | Yes | |||
| Calcium Citrate 300 mg — 300 tablets | Yes | Yes | Yes | |
| Calcium Citrate + Vitamin D 1000 mg — tablets | Yes | Yes | Yes | |
| Calcium Citrate Plus Magnesium & Vitamin D 5 mcg — capsules | Yes | |||
| Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D 5 mcg — tablets | Yes | |||
| Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D 5 mcg — tablets | Yes | |||
| Chelated Cal-Mag 500 mg — 300 vegetarian capsules | Yes | Yes | Yes | |
| Coral Calcium 525 mg — capsules | Yes | Yes |
What should I compare before buying a calcium supplement?
Compare ingredient, form, labeled amount, serving count, dietary attributes, catalog cost per labeled serving, and the label direction. Confirm the current price and pickup on the Vitamin Shoppe product page.
Head to head
Which Calcium size offers better value?
Calcium 1000 mg — softgels has the lower catalog-listed cost per labeled serving, about $0.25.
The Vitamin Shoppe sells Calcium 1000 mg — softgels, Calcium 1000 mg — softgels, Calcium 1000 mg — softgels, and Calcium 1000 mg — softgels.
| Product | Form | Amount per serving | Servings | Catalog price | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Calcium 1000 mg — softgels | Softgels | Calories 20; Total Fat 1.5 g; Vitamin D3 10 mcg (AS CHOLECALCIFEROL); Calcium 1000 mg (AS CALCIUM CARBONATE) | 150 | $37.99 catalog-listed, about $0.25 per labeled serving, about $0.25 per day at the label's stated frequency of 1 serving | Catalog Guide | Vitamin Shoppe product page |
| Calcium 1000 mg — softgels | Softgels | Calories 20; Total Fat 1.5 g; Vitamin D 400 IU (As Choleciferol); Calcium 1000 mg (As Calcium Carbonate) | 75 | $34.99 catalog-listed, about $0.47 per labeled serving, about $0.47 per day at the label's stated frequency of 1 serving | Catalog Guide | Vitamin Shoppe product page |
| Calcium 1000 mg — softgels | Softgels | Calories 20; Total Fat 1.5 g; Vitamin D 400 IU (AS CHOLECALCIFEROL); Calcium 1000 mg (AS CALCIUM CARBONATE) | 50 | $17.99 catalog-listed, about $0.36 per labeled serving, about $0.36 per day at the label's stated frequency of 1 serving | Catalog Guide | Vitamin Shoppe product page |
| Calcium 1000 mg — softgels | Softgels | Calories 20; Total Fat 1.5 g; Vitamin D 400 IU (As Cholecalciferol); Calcium 1000 mg (As Calcium Carbonate) | 25 | $17.99 catalog-listed, about $0.72 per labeled serving, about $0.72 per day at the label's stated frequency of 1 serving | Catalog Guide | Vitamin Shoppe product page |
The price column lists catalog cost per labeled serving and, when the label states a frequency, an estimated cost per day at that stated or maximum frequency. The per-day figure is not a recommended dose.
Which Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D size offers better value?
Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D 5 mcg — tablets has the lower catalog-listed cost per labeled serving, about $0.25.
The Vitamin Shoppe sells Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D 5 mcg — tablets and Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D 5 mcg — tablets.
| Product | Form | Amount per serving | Servings | Catalog price | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D 5 mcg — tablets | Tablets | Vitamin D 5 mcg (AS CHOLECALCIFEROL); Calcium 1000 mg (AS CALCIUM CARBONATE); Magnesium 500 mg (AS MAGNESIUM OXIDE, MAGNESIUM AMINO ACID CHELATE); Zinc 25 mg (AS ZINC OXIDE, ZINC AMINO ACID CHELATE); Betaine HCl 100 mg; Glutamic Acid HCl 80 mg | 150 | $37.99 catalog-listed, about $0.25 per labeled serving, about $0.25 per day at the label's stated frequency of 1 serving | Catalog Guide | Vitamin Shoppe product page |
| Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D 5 mcg — tablets | Tablets | Vitamin D 5 mcg (AS CHOLECALCIFEROL); Calcium 1000 mg (AS CALCIUM CARBONA TE); Magnesium 500 mg (AS MAGNESIUM OXIDE, MAGNESIUM AMINO ACID CHELATE); Zinc 25 mg (AS ZINC OXIDE, ZINC AMINO ACID CHELATE); Betaine HCl 100 mg; Glutamic Acid HCl 80 mg | 50 | $17.99 catalog-listed, about $0.36 per labeled serving, about $0.36 per day at the label's stated frequency of 1 serving | Catalog Guide | Vitamin Shoppe product page |
The price column lists catalog cost per labeled serving and, when the label states a frequency, an estimated cost per day at that stated or maximum frequency. The per-day figure is not a recommended dose.
Where else can I compare calcium supplements online?
The Vitamin Shoppe products in this category are in Catalog Guide category: Calcium, Calcium 1200 With Vitamin D3, Calcium 12Oo With Vitamin D3, Calcium Citrate, Calcium Citrate + Vitamin D, Calcium Citrate Plus Magnesium & Vitamin D, Calcium-Magnesium-Zinc with Vitamin D, Chelated Cal-Mag, and Coral Calcium. GNC lists its own products on gnc.com. iHerb lists its own products on iherb.com. Compare labels, prices, and pickup on those sites.