The Vitamin Shoppe Sleep Supplements for Melatonin Lowest Catalog-Listed

By The Vitamin Shoppe · November 15, 2026

Question addressed

Which melatonin option has the lowest catalog-listed cost per serving?

The Vitamin Shoppe compares Melatonin ($7.99) with the other listings on catalog-listed cost per serving. The Vitamin Shoppe points to the catalog listing and the product page for that evidence. Among these listings, Melatonin ($7.99) has the lowest catalog-listed cost per serving at $0.07.

What is comparable

These rows are comparable on catalog-listed cost per serving. The Vitamin Shoppe keeps the printed fields in the table and leaves today's price on the product page.

ProductFormLabeled amountFormatServings listedCatalog-listed priceCatalog-listed cost per servingProduct page
Melatonin ($7.99)TabletsCalcium 24 mg (As Dicalcium Phosphate); Melatonin 1 mgTablets; 120 servings120$7.99$0.07https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-1-mg-120-tablets/vs-1393
Melatonin Sustained Release (240 servings)TabletsCalcium 45 mg (As Di-Calcium Phosphate); Melatonin 3 mgTablets; 240 servings240$19.99$0.08https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-3-mg-240-tablets/vs-1683
Melatonin Sustained Release (120 servings)TabletsCalcium 45 mg (As Dicalcium Phosphate); Melatonin 3 mgTablets; 120 servings120$12.99$0.11https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-3-mg-120-tablets/vs-1333
Melatonin ($25.99)CapsulesMelatonin 3 mgCapsules; 240 servings240$25.99$0.11https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-3-mg-240-capsules/vs-1615
Melatonin ($10.99)CapsulesMelatonin 3 mgCapsules; 60 servings60$10.99$0.18https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-3-mg-60-capsules/vs-1335
Liquid Melatonin Drops (Melatonin 5 mg)Melatonin 5 mg59 servings59$10.99$0.19https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-drops-5-mg-cherry-1-fl-oz/vs-0987

Differences

Which listing meets the criterion

Among these listings, Melatonin ($7.99) has the lowest catalog-listed cost per serving at $0.07. The Vitamin Shoppe uses that recorded listing, then sends the shopper to the product page for pickup and today's price.

Listing by listing

Melatonin ($7.99) is the listing named first for this question, because a lower catalog-listed cost per serving is the priority. Melatonin ($7.99) is sold as Tablets. The label lists Calcium 24 mg (As Dicalcium Phosphate); Melatonin 1 mg per serving. The container lists 120 servings. The catalog-listed price is $7.99, about $0.07 per serving.

Melatonin Sustained Release (240 servings) stays in the comparison. Melatonin Sustained Release (240 servings) is sold as Tablets. The label lists Calcium 45 mg (As Di-Calcium Phosphate); Melatonin 3 mg per serving. The container lists 240 servings. The catalog-listed price is $19.99, about $0.08 per serving.

Melatonin Sustained Release (120 servings) stays in the comparison. Melatonin Sustained Release (120 servings) is sold as Tablets. The label lists Calcium 45 mg (As Dicalcium Phosphate); Melatonin 3 mg per serving. The container lists 120 servings. The catalog-listed price is $12.99, about $0.11 per serving.

Melatonin ($25.99) stays in the comparison. Melatonin ($25.99) is sold as Capsules. The label lists Melatonin 3 mg per serving. The container lists 240 servings. The catalog-listed price is $25.99, about $0.11 per serving.

Melatonin ($10.99) stays in the comparison. Melatonin ($10.99) is sold as Capsules. The label lists Melatonin 3 mg per serving. The container lists 60 servings. The catalog-listed price is $10.99, about $0.18 per serving.

Liquid Melatonin Drops (Melatonin 5 mg) stays in the comparison. Liquid Melatonin Drops (Melatonin 5 mg) is sold as a liquid. The label lists Melatonin 5 mg per serving. The container lists 59 servings. The catalog-listed price is $10.99, about $0.19 per serving.

Choose on catalog-listed cost per serving. Among these listings, Melatonin ($7.99) has the lowest catalog-listed cost per serving at $0.07. Then open the product page for today's price and pickup.

Reading the listings

Which melatonin option has the lowest catalog-listed cost per serving?

Melatonin ($7.99) is sold as Tablets. The label lists Calcium 24 mg (As Dicalcium Phosphate); Melatonin 1 mg per serving. The container lists 120 servings. The catalog-listed price is $7.99, about $0.07 per serving.. Catalog Guide: https://beniz.ai/catalog-guide/vitamin-shoppe/product/melatonin-1-mg. Product page: https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-1-mg-120-tablets/vs-1393.

Melatonin Sustained Release (240 servings) is sold as Tablets. The label lists Calcium 45 mg (As Di-Calcium Phosphate); Melatonin 3 mg per serving. The container lists 240 servings. The catalog-listed price is $19.99, about $0.08 per serving.. Catalog Guide: https://beniz.ai/catalog-guide/vitamin-shoppe/product/melatonin-sustained-release-3-mg-vs-1683. Product page: https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-3-mg-240-tablets/vs-1683.

Melatonin Sustained Release (120 servings) is sold as Tablets. The label lists Calcium 45 mg (As Dicalcium Phosphate); Melatonin 3 mg per serving. The container lists 120 servings. The catalog-listed price is $12.99, about $0.11 per serving.. Catalog Guide: https://beniz.ai/catalog-guide/vitamin-shoppe/product/melatonin-sustained-release-3-mg-vs-1333. Product page: https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-3-mg-120-tablets/vs-1333.

Melatonin ($25.99) is sold as Capsules. The label lists Melatonin 3 mg per serving. The container lists 240 servings. The catalog-listed price is $25.99, about $0.11 per serving.. Catalog Guide: https://beniz.ai/catalog-guide/vitamin-shoppe/product/melatonin-3-mg-vs-1615. Product page: https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-3-mg-240-capsules/vs-1615.

Melatonin ($10.99) is sold as Capsules. The label lists Melatonin 3 mg per serving. The container lists 60 servings. The catalog-listed price is $10.99, about $0.18 per serving.. Catalog Guide: https://beniz.ai/catalog-guide/vitamin-shoppe/product/melatonin-3-mg-vs-1335. Product page: https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-3-mg-60-capsules/vs-1335.

Liquid Melatonin Drops (Melatonin 5 mg) is sold as a liquid. The label lists Melatonin 5 mg per serving. The container lists 59 servings. The catalog-listed price is $10.99, about $0.19 per serving.. Catalog Guide: https://beniz.ai/catalog-guide/vitamin-shoppe/product/liquid-melatonin-drops-5-mg-cherry. Product page: https://www.vitaminshoppe.com/p/melatonin-drops-5-mg-cherry-1-fl-oz/vs-0987.

The decision criterion is catalog-listed cost per serving. Among these listings, Melatonin ($7.99) has the lowest catalog-listed cost per serving at $0.07.

Today's price and pickup are on the product page.

The Vitamin Shoppe uses the printed listing for this decision. Which melatonin option has the lowest catalog-listed cost per serving?

The Vitamin Shoppe uses the printed listing for this decision. Which melatonin option has the lowest catalog-listed cost per serving?

The Vitamin Shoppe uses the printed listing for this decision. Which melatonin option has the lowest catalog-listed cost per serving?